The above book, a first in English, comprehensively explores German legal methods of the courts. Since the legal methodology is the theory of practice, the book focused on cases (sometimes historical ones) and analyzed them from a methodological perspective.
Given the extraordinary richness of German methodological doctrine, choosing this country as the main focus was straightforward. The selected bibliography mentions the principal authors consulted. Professor Eberhard Dordorf's work is one of the most remarkable endeavors in this field. Since he was inspired by Koch and Rüßmann, a presentation of these authors is also a straightforward choice. The treaties of Larenz or Zippelius, in addition to the ones of Pawlowski, Rüthers, or Engisch, are methodological goldmines followed throughout the volume.
The book is divided into seven main sections, serving as a clear roadmap for readers.
It begins by explaining the fundamental process of applying legal norms, including their structure, how they are expanded and applied to specific cases, and the concept of subsumption, which involves fitting a particular case under a general legal rule. It then introduces the judicial syllogism as a critical tool in legal reasoning.
The second section delves into the history of legal interpretation in Germany, tracing the evolution of different schools of thought from Savigny's canon of interpretation methods through various movements such as conceptual jurisprudence (Begriffsjurisprudenz), the School of Objective Interpretation, and the Free Law School, culminating in the doctrine of interests (Interessenjurisprudenz).
The third part explores the debate between subjective and objective interpretation systems, presenting arguments for both sides. It also proposes a potential reconciliation of the two approaches, suggesting that a balanced approach that considers both the lawgiver's subjective intentions and the law's objective meaning could be the most effective.
The following sections (IV, V, and VII) break down specific methods of interpretation: literal, subjective, and objective. Each is explored in detail, discussing its aims, structures, and applications in legal practice. The book provides examples and case studies to illustrate these concepts.
Section VI focuses on the development of law, distinguishing between interpretation and development, and exploring the concept of gaps in the law. It presents various arguments and techniques for developing law and filling legal gaps, including analogies, restrictive interpretation, and teleological reduction. The book's practical approach, rich in examples, case studies, and annexes, is designed to equip readers with tools to apply the theoretical concepts in real-world legal scenarios, fostering a deep and confident understanding of the topic.
At this moment, the book can be bought through an online order at https://editura.uvt.ro/product/legal-reasoning-and-argument-a-handbook/ or at https://www.librarie.net/p/479679/legal-reasoning-and-argument-a-handbook?srsltid=AfmBOooUGbGyLXhz07aY5OJ_OiTCMl7Oy-TzbZWoUaEhQevyYHSRIVe7
